Pick the kind of night first. The seven current cocktail bars in our St. Augustine records do different jobs, from a bayfront martini to a full dinner under an old ice crane.
If the deal or the time matters first, use the St. Augustine happy hour and bar specials board before choosing the room.
| Bar | Go here when | Useful difference | Area |
|---|
| Ice Plant Bar | The drinks and the building both matter | House cocktails and a full kitchen inside a 1927 ice plant | Lincolnville |
|---|
| Forgotten Tonic | You want cocktails with dinner | An Aviles Street room with a full food menu | Old City |
|---|
| Tini Martini Bar | The bay view is part of the drink | A verandah facing Matanzas Bay | Old City |
|---|
| Boat Drinks | Rum and seafood sound right | A rum-forward bar with its own parking lot | Uptown |
|---|
| Odd Birds | You are already crossing the bridge | A cocktail lounge and kitchen in Davis Shores | Davis Shores |
|---|
| Prohibition Kitchen | The group wants food and music too | A large St. George Street room with a full kitchen | Old City |
|---|
| Barley Republic | Beer and whiskey share the vote | An Irish gastropub near the City Gate | Old City |
|---|
The parking difference can decide the bar
Boat Drinks has its own parking lot. The Old City rooms work better when you park once and walk. Use the St. Augustine bar parking guide before the first loop around downtown starts eating the night.
Venue details were checked against official and dated public sources through September 30, 2026. Menus, music, and parking access can change.